The need to upgrade health insurance scheme

The need to upgrade health insurance scheme

The imposition of sanctions against erring healthcare facilities (HCFs) and health maintenance organisations under the National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS) is a long overdue action that should be sustained for the objectives of the crucial programme to be effectively realised. The NHIS began in this country 22 years ago majorly to bail out many Nigerians who are unable to afford quality healthcare service for themselves and families when they need it most. It is distressing that since then, the story about the scheme has largely been that of castigation due to corruption, negligence and bad attitude of the service providers, among other challenges confronting its implementation. And sadly, many Nigerians who are supposed to benefit from the scheme have continued to languish in various health problems. What the citizens want to hear from the authorities is not only about the sanctions, which is capable of creating a deceptive impression of seriousness on the part of the government to make the scheme work, but also the sincere and practical steps being made to ensure quality service delivery going forward, and to tackle the sharp practices by the stakeholders, especially the service providers, in such a way that Nigerians will see new HCFs, Health management Offices (HMOs) and designated hospitals dedicated to implementation of the scheme as designed. In the 2024 Annual Complaints Report of the NHIS, it was highlighted that about 49 HCFs and 47 health maintenance organizations were sanctioned in 2024 by the National Health Insurance Authority (NHIA) for poor quality of services to enrollees against the monitoring agencys operational guidelines. The action of the NHIA did not just happen. It followed complaints received from patients by NHIA, which were investigated and found to be true. The report listed the key issues in the complaints against the HCFs and others as non-availability of medicines to be dispensed to enrolled patients, denial of services, out-of-pocket payments for covered services and non-provision of payment narrations. In the report issued in compliance with the NHIA Act 17 of 2022 which requires the Authority to establish mechanism for receiving and resolving complaints by members of the scheme and healthcare facilities, it was stated that in all, 3507 complaints were received during the period out of which 2,929 (84%), the majority of which were against the HCFs were resolved. The distribution shows 2,273 reports were against HCFs, 1,232 against HMOs and only two reports were against enrollees by service providers. The sanctions came in various forms: Formal warning was issued to 84 HCFs while four were suspended, 35 HMOs got warning letters and directives to institute corrective actions, as six were delisted. In all, 54 enrollees got refunds of N4, 375 500 from 39 HCFs while 12 HMOs were directed to refund N748, 200 to 15 enrollees.

While the efforts of the NHIS at resolving complaints are welcome, there is need for stronger action against erring service providers. The scheme is crucial for survival of many Nigerians and, therefore, must not fail. What is meant to be achieved is the kernel of the constitutional declaration that security and welfare of the people shall be the primary purpose of government. The health of Nigerians is the wealth of Nigeria because the productivity of a country depends largely on the health of the population. The shameful corruption and wanton disregard for human life that are becoming endemic and almost institutionalized in Nigeria should never be allowed to kill the NHIS. The World Bank in 2021 put Nigerias life expectancy rate at 54.69 years far below the 78.79 years in the United States and 81.20 years in the United Kingdom. This wide gap should be a major concern to authorities in Nigeria to stimulate a successful health insurance scheme. To this end, there should be a major overhaul of the NHIS. Part of the task should be to investigate the cause of inferior services being rendered and to move strongly against the corruption in the scheme. Why are the HCFs, HMOs and hospitals not following the guidelines? Could it be that the deal is no longer profitable for them and something needs to be done, or is the scheme simply prone to fraud? Why is drugs not available, prompting resort to substandard ones? Certain procedure may need to be reviewed jointly by the stakeholders for smooth running of the programme, but it must be done in a way that additional burden is not placed on the citizens that the intervention is meant to assist. The NHIA should come up with an official mechanism for occasional reappraisal of the implementation of the scheme instead of waiting for complaints by the enrollees. The allegation of low quality services is real. Even a study conducted at the NHIS Clinic of the Kubwa General Hospital, a major referral centre in Abuja, between November 2016 and March 2017 and published on the online platform of the National Library of Medicine found the complaints to be authentic. This violates the sanctity of human life. Any service provider who is found to be making things difficult for enrollees to enjoy their desired healthcare should be severely sanctioned, while the loopholes working against an efficient health insurance in the country should be plugged. Service providers should always be explicit about the level of access to treatment that the holder of each health insurance package or plan can get. Many enrollees have expressed disappointment over denial of some medical services at the point of need when they were told that the insurance package to which they subscribed did not allow them such services except they were ready to pay more money. Also, Nigerians need to be constantly educated about the scheme and how they can benefit from it, particularly during emergencies.

State governments that have not started implementing their own health insurance schemes are earnestly advised to do so to widen the coverage while those already providing the services should ensure faithful implementation. Health insurance is working in many other countries; there is no reason why it should not work in Nigeria. Nigerians deserve access to quality and affordable health services, in line with the letter and spirit of the countrys constitution.

Tags
Share

Related articles